Page 1 of 1
Posted: 02 Dec 2008, 21:15
by woodslanding
Can we get the standard use of ctl-A back? Maybe as a global option for compatibility.
I'm used to ctl-shift-s for saveAs and ctl-A for select all. All the software I use follows this convention, and especially working on scripts and going back and forth from a text editor, it drives me crazy!
thanks for listening!
-eric
Posted: 03 Dec 2008, 15:29
by senso
It's an historical choise. And I know that the CTRL+A is not standard in usine.
Maybe it's time to start a more global reflexion on all the short-cuts.
Posted: 03 Dec 2008, 18:17
by woodslanding
well, you could also create a table for the user. That's becoming more and more common....
Other small things:
I also am having problems wanting to put tabs in the script window... and I'm used to dragging to select multiple objects. I really like the way usine moves the frame of view, but I would put that under a ctl-key if I had a choice, just for consistency with other programs.
not the #1 issue, but.... I do think these kinds of conventions are important to keep in mind.
cheers!
-eric
Posted: 03 Dec 2008, 19:12
by woodslanding
one other little gui gripe:
the 'timeout' on popup texfields. I realize I shouldn't leave the refrigerator door open while I'm deciding what to eat.... but--I do!
the need to double-click on list boxes to select an item. this one I got used to pretty quickly, but it confused me a LOT when I was first starting out.
-e
Posted: 04 Dec 2008, 18:10
by Vincent
Hi,
You're right, Wodslanding, shortcuts are somewhat confusing (and keystroke+clicks too).
When you patch modular stuffs in Usine, then in Reaktor, then back in Usine, then... you just turn crazy!
I would also add the very popular ctrl+C, ctrl+X and Ctrl+V (copy, cut, paste) that don't work the same way in parameters textfiels, in patches textfields (typically the patch name), in the patching window (or sequencer) and so on.
I've already seen ctrl+L for Select All, in some cheap softs, but Usine is NOT a cheap soft!!!!
I think that Olivier is right: it's great time now to nomalize that according to the softs-world usage.
Maybe a customizable table, why not, but what is really important for ergonomy is to have first the right usual shortcut keys (ctrl-F9 for compilation is the right one, for example).
That's an old question now.
Certainly not so easy to perfectly implement everywhere in the gui...
Posted: 04 Dec 2008, 19:08
by senso
the actual logic for short cuts is:
ctrl for wkp
ctrl+alt for patches
I think it's quite comfortable like that. the only big conflict is with the ctrl+A (save as). but I can't find a better candidate...
Posted: 04 Dec 2008, 22:53
by bsork
I don't really remember the most used save-as ctrl key combination is among all the various programs I use, but Ctrl-Shift-S is fairly common I think.
Posted: 05 Dec 2008, 08:41
by La Tenaille
Hi,
Ctrl-Shift-S is a convention used in almost all the open source softs. Of course, let's forget window$

Posted: 05 Dec 2008, 09:36
by senso
the [Ctrl-Shift-S] is not standard at all.
And if we want to respect the [ctrl] for wkp and [ctrl-alt] for patches it means that 'save as' will be:
[ctrl+shift+s] for wkp and [ctrl+shift+alt+s] for patches...tricky because we need 2 hands...
The ideal solution doesn't exist?
Posted: 06 Dec 2008, 02:11
by woodslanding
well then, maybe best to let the user choose via table. Although I can get ctl-alt-shift-s with one hand on my laptop.
I almost always 'saveAs' from the menu anyway--since I have to type in a new name, it's never just a quick keycommand like saving is....
Posted: 06 Dec 2008, 09:39
by La Tenaille
ctrl+shift+s and ctrl+shift+alt+s are used in Photoshop for example (save as and save for the web).
One hand also ok for me
not against personal keymaping

Posted: 06 Dec 2008, 12:18
by senso
ok, if you prefer;
let's try your suggestions.